1847 at the Stamm House (4)1855 Saloon & Grill4 Mile Restaurant & Bar5100 - CLOSED (4)5th Quarter Sports Bar and Grill (9)608 Sports Bar - CLOSEDAC TapAlchemy (8)Ale Asylum - CLOSED (10)Alt 'N' Bachs Town Tap - CLOSED (2)Ama KitchenAmerican Legion Post 360American Legion Post 481Anchor at Lakeside Bar & Grill (6)Anchor Club IIAnchors Away - CLOSED (2)Angelic Brewing Company - CLOSEDAngelo's - McFarland (2)Angelo's - Monona - CLOSEDArgusAthens Grill (9)Atlantis Taverna - CLOSEDAvantis (2)Avenue Bar - CLOSED (8)Avenue Club and Bubble Up Bar - CLOSED (4)Aztalan Inn (3)Azzalinos - CLOSEDBabes At Vitense Grill And BarBabe's Grill & Bar - CLOSED (3)Badger Bowl - CLOSED (4)Badger Crossing (2)Badger Tavern (5)Baldwin Street Grille (5)Banushi's Bar & Grill - CLOSED (2)Banzo (Pop-Up) (2)Barber's Bay Inn - CLOSED (2)Barking CrabBarrel InnBassett Street Brunch ClubBay 5 Diner - CLOSEDBayou - CLOSEDBayside TavernBB Jack's - DeForest (2)Beach House Bar & Grill @ Sands of Kahana ResortBeachhouse - CLOSED (11)Bear & BottleBeaver's Bar & Grill - CLOSEDBeef Butter BBQ (2)Bennett's Meadowood County Club (2)Big 10 Pub (23)Black Bear Inn TavernBlackhawk Grille - CLOSED (2)Blind Shot Social Club (2)Blue Gilly's Pancake Pier - CLOSEDBlue Moon (10)Boathouse at the EdgewaterBogey FactoryBorgen's Cafe Borland's Tavern (4)Borough Beer Co. & Kitchen - CLOSED (2)Boulder Brewpub - CLOSEDBourbon Street Grille - CLOSEDBowl-A-Vard LanesBranch Street Retreat - CLOSED (5)Brass Ring (2)Brat und Brau - CLOSEDBreakwater (2)Brennan's Cellars (8)Bridges on the Green (8)Brocach - Downtown - CLOSED (5)Brocach - Monroe - CLOSEDBrothers Three - CLOSED (13)Buck & Badger - CLOSED (2)Buck & Honey's - Monona (2)Buck & Honey's - Sun Prairie (5)Buck & Honey's - Waunakee (4)Buckhorn Supper ClubBuckingham'sBunky's Deli - CLOSED (3)Buraka - CLOSEDButterbirdByrd's Pub and Grill - CLOSEDCafe California - CLOSEDCafe Hollander (4)Cahoots Bar (8)Camelot Bar and GrillCamp TrippalindeeCannery Grill - CLOSED (2)Capital Tap Haus - CLOSED (2)Capitol Chophouse - CLOSEDCapri Steak House - CLOSEDCaptain Bill's - CLOSED (2)Cash & Olive's (2)Castle Hill Supper ClubChanitcleer InnCherokee Country Club: The Sequoia Room (2)ChilisChristy's Landing (3)Cider Farm - CLOSEDCity Bar (4)Claddaugh - CLOSEDClub 60 (2)Club Lamark (2)Club Tavern - CLOSED (2)Coachman's Golf ResortCoach's Club - CLOSEDColiseum Bar & Banquet - CLOSEDComeback In (2)Common Ground - CLOSEDCoopers Tavern (3)CoppsCornerstone PubCottage Cafe (4)Country BarCountry Cafe - CLOSEDCountry Corners - CLOSED (2)Country Gardens Motel & Lounge (2)Country Place Cafe - CLOSEDCounty ClareCow & Quince - CLOSEDCraftsman Table & Tap (3)Cranberry Creek - CLOSEDCrandall's - CLOSED (3)Crapp's Tap - CLOSEDCrawfish Junction (16)Crossroads Bar and GrillCulver's - Edgerton (I-90)Culver's - Madison (Northside)Dahmen's at Hawk's Landing (3)Daisy Cafe & Cupcakery - CLOSEDDale's Place - CLOSEDDaly's Bar & Grill (3)Dam BarDave's South Bay Lounge & Grill - CLOSED (2)David W. Heiney's - CLOSED (5)Deak's Pub & Grill (6)DearbornDeBroux's Diner - CLOSED (2)DeBroux's on Lake Monona - CLOSED (2)Decoy Bar & Grill - CLOSEDDeForest Family RestaurantDelaney's Charcol SteaksDel-BarDeli Delicious - CLOSED (2)Der Rathskeller - Memorial UnionDexter's Pub (64)Dirtwater SpringsDJ's Shortstop Bar & Grill - CLOSED (3)Dobhan - CLOSEDDog House Bar & GrillDolphin's Bar & Grill - CLOSEDDorf Haus (8)Dotty Dumpling's Dowry (2)Dotty's Bar & Bistro - CLOSEDDoubleday's (2)Double S BBQ - CLOSEDDraft House (3)Driftless CaféDriftless Social (2)Driftwood GrilleDuck Inn Supper ClubDuck Pond @ Warner Park (3)Dutch Inn WestDutch Mill Sports ClubEast Johnson Family Restaurant - CLOSEDEast Side Club (4)Easy Landing (2)EatStreet's Catch & Reel - CLOSEDEcho Tap (4)Eddie's Ale HouseEldorado Grill - CLOSED (2)Elephant & CastleElias Inn Supper Club - CLOSEDElla's Deli - CLOSEDEl Poblano - CLOSEDEpic SystemsErin's Snug Irish Pub (2)Esquire Club - CLOSED (13)EverlyFarm Sports Pub - CLOSEDFat Jack'sFat SeagullFeiler's - CLOSED (7)Final ScoreFireside Supper ClubFireside TheatreFisherman's OutletFish Tales (4)Fitzgerald's of Middleton - CLOSED (8)Fitz's on the Lake (8)Flannery's Wilhelm Tell - CLOSEDFountain - CLOSED (2)Fraternal Order of Eagles - ViroquaFreddy Valentine's - CLOSEDFred & Fuzzy's Waterfront Bar & Grill - CLOSEDFredrick's Supper Club (3)Free House Pub & Grill (3)Freiburg Gastropub - CLOSEDFriendly Tavern (2)Frog Pond (3)Full Mile Beer Company & Kitchen (2)Funk's Pub - CLOSED (2)Game Time Sports Bar and Grill (2)Gasser's Bar & Grill (2)Gates & Brovi (7)Glarner Stube (3)Glass Nickel (14)Good Co. Pioneer Pointe - CLOSED (5)Gourmet HallGranite City - CLOSEDGray's Tied House - CLOSEDGraze (5)Great Dane - Downtown (3)Great Dane - FitchburgGreat Dane - Hilldale - CLOSEDGreen Acres (2)Green Lantern (7)Green Owl CafeGreenwood Supper Club - CLOSEDGreyDrake SaloonGrowler's Bar & Grille - CLOSEDGrumpy TrollGus' DinerGym Bar & Grill (3)Hack's Sports Page - CLOSEDHail Mary Sports Bar and Grill - CLOSEDHalverson's Supper Club - CLOSED (3)Hank's Burgers & Fish Fry (3)Harmony Bar & Grill (2)Hawk'sHawthorn's - CLOSED (2)Headquarters Bar & Grill Hen House Bar and GrillHerreman's - CLOSED (2)Hideaway Pub & GrillHighland Corner GrillHilltop (4)Hilltop Inn - CLOSED (3)Hi Point Steak House (2)Hoehn's Huddle (2)Holstein - CLOSEDHooker's Resort (2)Hooterville Inn (9)Hopcat - CLOSEDHop Haus Brewing CompanyHoughtons' Fine Food-Cocktails (2)Hound - CLOSED (8)Howie's on La CrosseHubbard Avenue DinerHubbleton Brewing Co. Taproom & GrillHungry Peddler (4)Hy-Vee (2)Ian's Pizza (2)Icehouse at the EdgewaterICU Bar & GrillImmaculate Heart Of Mary School (2)Ironworks Cafe at the Goodman Center - CLOSEDjacs Dining and Tap - CLOSED (3)JB's Italian Grille - CLOSEDJerzy's Eagle Crest BarJim's Meat Market - CLOSEDJJ's La Puerta - CLOSED (5)JJ's Top of The Swamp - CLOSED (2)Jodi's Bar and Grill - CLOSEDJoe Senser'sJT's Porch Saloon & Eatery (2)Judy's Burger & GrinderKD's Bar & Grill (8)Kegel's Inn Kickapoo CreeksideKickapoo Inn - CLOSEDK.K. Fiske Restaurant, Granary Saloon & Coop HangoutKlassik Tavern - CLOSED (3)Klubhouse @ Hawks Landing - CLOSED (2)Koffee Kup (3)KOSKristi's RestaurantKurNiki's (8)Kwik Trip (North Side) (3)Lake Edge Seafood Co. - CLOSED (2)Lakefront Brewery (3)Lake Windsor Golf Club's Bar & Grill (3)Laurel Tavern (5)Layla's Labor Temple Lounge - CLOSEDLazy Oaf Lounge (2)Legal Sea Foods - Copley PlaceLegends Sports Bar and Grill - CLOSED (2)Licari's Tavern (4)LJ's Sports Tavern and Grill (6)Local TavernLocker Room Sports BarLockwood's Longshot (3)Logan's Madtown - CLOSEDLone Girl Brewing Company (5)Longtable Beer Cafe (8)Lucky 13 SaloonLucky's 1313 Brew Pub (2)Lucky's Bar & Grille - Madison - CLOSED (4)Lucky's Bar & Grille - Waunakee - CLOSEDLucky's on the LakeMac's Stumble Out PubMad City Frites - CLOSEDMadison Blind - CLOSEDMadison's (2)Maple Tree Supper Club (6)Marcine's - CLOSEDMaricque's (2)Mariner's Inn - CLOSED (5)Mark's East SideMars ResortMartin O' Gradys - CLOSED (2)Mason's on Main - CLOSED (5)Maui Fish'n ChipsMax's Farm Table - CLOSED (2)McBob's Pub & Grill (2)McFarland TavernMcGovern's Club - CLOSED (2)Me & JulioMelly Mell's Dining & Catering - CLOSED (3)Mendota Grill - Memorial UnionMerchantMichele's RestaurantMickey's Tavern (5)Middleton Sport Bowl (15)Mid Town Pub (9)Milford Hills Hunt ClubMiller Time Pub & GrillMint Mark - CLOSED (8)Moe's Tavern and Grill - CLOSEDMojo's Sports Pub & Grill - CLOSED (2)Monkeyshines Bar & Grill - CLOSEDMonk's Bar & Grill - MiddletonMonk's Bar & Grill - Sun PrairieMonk's Retreat - CLOSEDMontag's Pub and Grill - CLOSED (2)Monte's Grill & Pub - CLOSEDMonty's Blue Plate Diner (2)Morels - CLOSEDMorgan's Bar & Grill - CLOSED (5)Mothers - CLOSEDMount Vernon TapMr. Brews - JunctionMulligan's Bar & Grill - CLOSED (4)Murphy's Bar & Restaurant (2)Murphy's Tavern - CLOSEDMy Buddies - CLOSEDNau-ti-gal - CLOSED (3)Nelson's Crossing - CLOSED (5)New Glarus Hotel - CLOSEDNext Door Brewing Company - CLOSED (3)Nick's Restaurant - CLOSED (4)Nite Cap InnNitty Gritty - Downtown (2)Nitty Gritty - MiddletonNomad World Pub - CLOSED (2)Nora's Two (2)Nordic LanesNorm's Hideaway - CLOSEDNorth and South Seafood and Smokehouse - DeForestNorth and South Seafood and Smokehouse - Madison (12)North Bristol Sportsman's Club (4)North of the BayouNorwegian Hollow Hideaway Bar and Grill (5)Oakcrest Tavern (8)Oakleaf Restaurant at The Oaks Golf CourseOakstone Recreational (3)Octopi Brewing (8)Off Broadway Drafthouse (7)Old Fashioned (12)Old Feed Mill (2)Old Republic Kitchen + BarOld Rock (2)Oliver's Public House - CLOSEDOllie's Madison (2)On the HookOpe Haus PubOrchardOrpheum Theatre - CLOSED (3)Otsego Yacht Clulb (2)Ott Haus Pub & Grill (4)Outpost Bar & GrillOwl's Nest - CLOSED (5)Paddy Mac's Pub & Grill (4)Paoli Pub & Grill (3)Papa Phils - CLOSED (2)Pape's Fair Valley Inn - CLOSED (2)Paradise LoungePark Side Pub (3)Pasture and Plenty (3)Patrick's Grill - CLOSEDPaul's Neighborhood Bar (4)Pedro's Mexican Restaurant - CLOSEDPeg & Doc's Sports Bar and Grill (14)Peninsula Pub - CLOSEDPhill's Bar & GrillPicasso's - Madison - CLOSED (4)Picasso's - McFarland - CLOSEDPickle Tree (2)Pier 290Pine Cone Restaurant - CLOSED (4)Pine Cove (4)PinsocialPlayer's Sports BarPooley's (6)Popeye's on Lake GenevaPostPrairie Diner - CLOSEDPrairie House Food & SpiritsPrairie Inn Supper Club - CLOSEDPrairie Lanes (2)Prost! MSN (2)Quivey's Grove (8)Ranieri's Four of a Kind Bar & GrillR BarReady Set - CLOSED (2)Red Lion - CLOSEDRed Mouse (3)Red Pines Bar & Grill (6)Red RobinRed Rooster - CLOSEDRegent Street Retreat - CLOSED (13)Remington's Tavern (5)Remi's Thirsty MooseRev. Jim's Roadhouse - CLOSED (2)Rex's Innkeeper (6)RidgeRigby Bar & GrillRight Bauer Brewing - CLOSEDRiver Inn BarRiviera Bowl & Pizzeria (2)R&J's Saloon - CLOSED (2)Roast Public House - CLOSEDRockhound Brewing Company - CLOSED (2)Rock Sports Bar and GrilleRockton BarRocky's Supper Club (3)Rodeside Grill (5)Rookies (2)Roost Pub & Grill - CLOSEDRosati's (4)Rossario's - CLOSED (2)Roxbury Bar & GrillRP Adler's (10)Rude's Lanes (3)Rustic HavenRyder's RoadhouseSaint Maria Goretti Catholic ParishSaint Michael Catholic ChurchSaint Peter Catholic Church (7)Saj's on Main - CLOSEDSalvatore's Tomato Pies - LivingstonSalvatore's Tomato Pies - MononaSalvatore's Tomato Pies - Sun Prairie (2)Sand BarSarento's Italian RestaurantSchneid's Sports Bar and Grill - CLOSED (5)Sconnie Bar (2)Seafood Center - Old Sauk - CLOSED (2)Seafood Center - Whitney WaySebastopol Brewing Co - CLOSEDSeminole TapSettle Down Tavern (2)Seven Seas Restaurant Shack (2)Shamrock Bar & Grill (2)ShedShelton's - CLOSEDShipwreck BayShopiere Tap (2)Side Door Grill and Tap (3)Sierra Nevada Brewing CompanySilver Eagle Bar & Grill (9)Sista's Chicken & FishSister Bay Bowl (7)Skål Public House - CLOSEDSlice's Bar & Grill (4)Slide Food Cart - CLOSED (2)Smitty's Study Pub (2)Smokin Cantina @ Alt Brewing Co. - CLOSEDSmoky's Club - CLOSEDSofra Family Bistro (Bavaria Cafe) (4)Sportsman's Reloaded (2)Sports Pub - CLOSED (2)Spot - CLOSEDSprecher's Restaurant and Pub - CLOSEDSpring Creek Restaurant & Bar - CLOSED (4)Spring Creek Tavern - CLOSED (3)Springers (3)Spring Lake InnSquirrel's Nest (3)Stadium Bar - CLOSED (3)Stalzy's Deli - CLOSED (11)Stamm House - CLOSED (6)StatehouseStockyard Grill & SaloonStolley's Hogg Alley (7)Stone Porch AlehouseSt. Paul Fish Company (2)Sugar and Spice Eatery & Deli - CLOSEDSugar River Lanes (4)Sundown SaloonSunset Bar & GrillSunset Harbor Bar & Grill (2)Swanson's Supper Club - CLOSEDSweet Home Wisconsin (3)Sweet Sophie's Restaurant & Hall - CLOSEDSyl's Place - CLOSEDTallard's Station - CLOSED (2)Talula - CLOSED (4)Tamarack II - CLOSED (3)Tap Room at Hawks Landing - CLOSED (2)Taverna Grill - CLOSEDTempest Oyster Bar (5)Ten Pin AlleyTexas RoadhouseThat BBQ Joint - CLOSEDThirsty Goat (5)Three Waters ReserveTimbers Tavern Bar & Grill (2)Tin Fox - CLOSED (2)Tipsy Cow - Madison (6)Tipsy Cow - Sun PrairieTip Top Tavern (16)TNT's Coffee and Cafe - CLOSED (2)Toby's Supper Club (43)Tofflers Pub & GrillTony Frank's - CLOSEDTornado Steak HouseTown Pump Bar and GrillTrader's Bar and GrillTravel Wisconsin Supper Club (Concession Stand)Tully's II (2)Tuman's Tap & GrillTurn Key (2)Twist Bar & Grill - CLOSEDUnion Corners Brewery - CLOSED (2)Utica Bar (3)Varsity Bar & Grill (2)Varsity Hall @ Union SouthVeranda Restaurant & Wine Bar - CLOSEDVerona Woods - CLOSEDVFW Post 1318VFW Post 3032VFW Post 328 (2)VFW Post 7591 (2)VFW Post 8483 (6)Viking Bar & Grill (4)Viking Brew Pub (2)Village Green (6)Village Tavern & Grill of Carol StreamVilla Inn - CLOSEDVilla Tap (73)Vintage Brewing Co. - Capitol EastVintage Brewing Co. - Cross PlainsVintage Brewing Co. - Madison (3)Vintage Brewing Co. - Sauk CityVintage Spirits and GrillWando's (15)Water Street TavernWatertower Chop House - CLOSED (4)Waypoint Public House (3)Wayside InnWay Station Saloon and EateryWeary Traveler Freehouse (2)WendigoWendt's on the Lake (3)Westby Rod & Gun ClubWestside Bar & GrillWest Side Club - CLOSED (3)Whippoorwill Tavern (8)Whiskey Run Distilling Co.Wigwam TavernWild Bull Bar and Grill - CLOSEDWildcat Lanes - CLOSEDWillie's Wet Spot - CLOSEDWillie Ty's - CLOSEDWillows TavernWill's Northwoods InnWilly Street EatsWilson's Sport's Bar & Grill (144)WindsorWissota High Shores Supper ClubWonder's Pub - CLOSED (2)Wood BBQ Restaurant & Catering - CLOSEDWoods Bar & GrillZander's Capitol Grill - CLOSED08/05/2026 - Bluegill06/08/2024 - Bluegill02/07/2024 - Bluegill02/28/2020 - Bluegill09/28/2019 - Bluegill05/04/2018 - Bluegill02/16/2018 - Cod07/05/2017 - Cod06/30/2017 - Bluegill05/16/2017 - Bluegill02/03/2017 - Bluegill04/29/2016 - Bluegill10/16/2015 - Bluegill09/04/2015 - Lake Perch08/28/2015 - Bluegill04/24/2015 - Bluegill04/17/2015 - Walleye07/18/2014 - Bluegill04/25/2014 - Bluegill03/14/2014 - Bluegill01/03/2014 - Lake Perch12/27/2013 - Bluegill11/01/2013 - Lake Perch09/06/2013 - Bluegill04/12/2013 - Bluegill01/04/2013 - Bluegill06/13/2012 - Bluegill06/13/2012 - Cod03/26/2011 - Bluegill03/11/2011 - Cod03/06/2009 - Cod06/09/2008 - Bluegill06/09/2008 - Cod05/14/2008 - Cod05/14/2008 - Bluegill01/18/2008 - Walleye01/18/2008 - Cod04/06/2007 - Cod04/06/2007 - Catfish04/06/2007 - Walleye04/06/2007 - Lake Perch01/05/2007 - Cod01/05/2007 - Walleye

Fish Type: Bluegill     Price: $19.00

Overall, I would highly recommend this Fish Fry.

Fish Score: Excellent Potato Score: Excellent Tartar Score: Excellent Bread Score: Excellent Miscellaneous Score: Excellent

www.tobyssupperclub.com/Home.html
3717 S Dutch Mill Road
Madison, WI 53718
(608) 222-6913